Subscribe to our newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest marketing, social media tips, guides and news.

Thank you! Now let's send you to the right place.
Oops! Something went wrong.
Please try again

Share

A black mouse on a yellow background with four wooden blocks with an image of an arrow on them.

Building credibility for online businesses in 10 ways

Last Updated

Originally Published

October 30, 2025

Author

Maggie Fogg

Sr. Brand Strategist

Building trust online is about consistency, authenticity, and transparency. In this post, we’ll explore 10 actionable ways to build credibility for your online business, from professional branding to secure payments and honest communication.

Starting an online business has never been easier. You can build a website in a day. Post a few clever TikToks. Share your brand story with the world. But getting people to trust your brand?

That’s the real challenge.

People’s trust doesn’t come from pretty logos or funny reels. It comes from: 

  • clear communication
  • consistent quality 
  • how you handle the challenging moments

Online buyers are cautious thanks to scams and poor service, making it twice as hard to earn their trust. Don’t know where to start? Here are 10 ways to build credibility and gain your target market’s trust.

1. Have a professional-looking website

People make up their minds fast. When someone lands on your site, they judge your business based on first impressions. If your design looks outdated or messy, they leave. 

A clean, professional-looking website instantly tells visitors you’re the real deal. Think of your site as your digital storefront; it’s the first thing people see. Follow web design trends that make sense for your brand. 

  • Don’t overload pages with chunky text.
  • Avoid flashing graphics.
  • Make navigation and shopping easy.

When people can easily navigate pages, they'll feel more assured that your business operates just as smoothly.

2. Stay active on social media

Nothing kills trust faster than silence. Social media isn’t just about promoting your creativity. It’s a way to show you’re active and engaged. Post regularly. Respond to comments. When it comes to content, highlight your team. Share stories from the brand’s work behind the scenes. Make bite-sized video content about your company’s story. This makes your brand feel authentic and legit. People like to see the humans behind the logo.

3. Share real customer stories

People believe other people more than they believe ads. Real experiences feel authentic. They make your brand look honest. Fake or exaggerated reviews break trust instantly. Encourage customers to share their stories; ask them to post photos of your products.

Then, repost this user-generated content on your own page. These testimonials show that your customers enjoy your products and services. When others see this social proof, they trust the brand naturally.

A young woman in a kitchen smiles at her laptop, headphones on.

Image Source: Shutterstock

4. Collaborate with credible voices

Collaborations foster trust; people trust those they know. Identify influencers who align with your brand's values and resonate with your audience. Then, reach out. Pitch a fun, mutually beneficial collaboration. Influencers help your brand grow because they speak the same language as your customers. Their fans already trust them and that trust extends to you by association.

5. Showcase social responsibility efforts

Today’s customers want to understand what your brand is about. If it seems like you’re just in it for the money, they’re likely to turn away. They’re interested in how you treat people and what you’re doing for the planet. 

When a business overlooks these things, trust and credibility take a hit. But when you show that you genuinely care, you can build trust. Social responsibility is important for marketing now because people expect brands to have a conscience. 

6. Make payments simple and secure

A complicated checkout process can drive customers away. To ensure trust, use familiar payment methods like cards and Apple Pay, and maintain a straightforward checkout page. Include clear indicators of security, such as a padlock symbol or SSL badge, to reassure customers.

For digital service businesses, like SEO or SEM agencies, payment trust can make or break the deal. Clients pay first, then they wait for the results. That gap can feel risky. Reputable SEO/SEM business payment solutions make it easier. These tools manage secure repeat billing for intangible deliverables.

7. Build a solid refund or dispute policy

Not everything goes as planned; products may disappoint, services can be delayed, and customers may be unhappy. Handle these situations gracefully. A clear refund or dispute policy demonstrates confidence in your products and fairness. Use simple language to outline what’s refundable, ensuring transparency to provide customers peace of mind before purchasing.

8. Reply to inquiries like a human

Robotic replies frustrate customers; a human touch is essential for better communication. AI is transforming digital marketing with chatbots and automation, but personal warmth remains essential. Use names and empathetic tones in responses. The result? Stronger relationships and higher trust in your brand.

9. Be transparent about data collection

Customers value privacy and may withdraw from brands that lack transparency about data usage. Being open about data collection and its purpose fosters trust. A small note that says, “We only use your data to improve your experience,” goes a long way. This builds trust before people even engage with your page.

Hands holding a green circle with a smiley face on it.

Image Source: Shutterstock

10. Act on customer feedback

Feedback is invaluable for improving your business. Every review and comment reveals customer opinions. Actively listen and respond to feedback to enhance your operations.

Regularly gather feedback through polls or email surveys about product experience and site navigation. Act on the insights gained, such as fixing confusing checkout pages or addressing negative feedback on features. When customers see their suggestions implemented, they feel valued, fostering trust and encouraging repeat business.

Trust takes time

Each post contributes to your business growth. Create a welcoming environment and listen to customer feedback to strengthen your brand. 

When customers feel comfortable, they’re more likely to spread the word about your brand. Work with an agency that can help you achieve this!

Key takeaways

FAQs

Why is credibility important for online businesses?

Credibility builds customer trust, which drives conversions, repeat purchases, and positive word-of-mouth. Without it, even great products struggle to sell.

How can small businesses appear more trustworthy online?

+

Start with a professional website, consistent branding, authentic customer reviews, and clear communication. Quick replies and transparent policies make a big difference.

What role does social media play in credibility?

+

An active social presence proves your business is real, responsive, and current. It helps build community and shows the human side of your brand.

Are reviews really that important?

+

Yes, people trust other customers far more than marketing copy. Genuine, verified reviews help reduce skepticism and boost conversions.

What’s one quick way to improve online credibility today?

+

Audit your website. Update outdated visuals, add security badges, fix broken links, and ensure your contact info is visible.

Written by

Maggie Fogg

Sr. Brand Strategist

Maggie Fogg is a Senior Brand Strategist at TIA with more than 15 years of experience across the marketing landscape. She is passionate about strategy, building fully integrated campaigns and bringing brand stories to life through engaging digital content. She is a fitness fanatic and avid traveller, who has visited 22 countries across six continents.